Without judging the situation or commenting on the Wisconsin affair, two side issues have occupied my thoughts. There are subtle differences in how democracy is understood in the States and in Germany.
I saw masses of protesters holding up panels with various slogans inside Madison's Capitol Building. It must have been physically challenging for senators to reach their chamber, not to mention the psychological effect such protesters certainly have on legislators.
Protesting crowds invading the building of a state parliament or the Bundestag in Berlin is unthinkable in Germany. While parliaments are in session, protesters are not allowed within a defined perimeter around the building so deputies can debate and vote undisturbed.
Protesting crowds invading the building of a state parliament or the Bundestag in Berlin is unthinkable in Germany. While parliaments are in session, protesters are not allowed within a defined perimeter around the building so deputies can debate and vote undisturbed.
The map taken from the German Wikipedia shows the perimeter around the Reichstag building in Berlin called Bannmeile. It is not called a kilometer but a mile, based on the distance measure used in various German territories before Germany's unification in 1871.
The Second Reich adopted the (French) metric system so everyone would use the same measure for distance and weight, and introduced a common currency, the Reichsmark.
The Bannmeile around the Reichstag is just a few hundred meters wide, not even a mile. Inside the perimeter, you find buildings that also house committee meeting rooms. The Bannmeile is valid only during scheduled sessions of the Bundestag.
In Germany, protests are frequent and taken seriously. In principle, authorities must be informed before and authorize the protest. Nevertheless, you find authorized and unauthorized protesters everywhere. Sometimes I think some participants are professionals traveling from protest to protest all over Germany. Official protests are even protected by the police against anti-protesters.
In Germany, protests are frequent and taken seriously. In principle, authorities must be informed before and authorize the protest. Nevertheless, you find authorized and unauthorized protesters everywhere. Sometimes I think some participants are professionals traveling from protest to protest all over Germany. Official protests are even protected by the police against anti-protesters.
There is a continuous protest in Freiburg each first Monday of the month against Hartz IV, a bundle of social laws that the Schröder government passed long ago. It is heart-warming to watch the lonely policeman walking along the marching half-dozen people until they settle on Freiburg's Rathausplatz, again only allowed when our city parliament is not in session.
The other minor difference between our democracies is that, apparently, in the States, deputies can be forced to be present for voting. In Germany, deputies simply walk out of their respective parliaments unhindered until the quorum is no longer reached.
The other minor difference between our democracies is that, apparently, in the States, deputies can be forced to be present for voting. In Germany, deputies simply walk out of their respective parliaments unhindered until the quorum is no longer reached.
In the States, Wisconsin senators unwilling to vote on the budget crossed the State boundary to be safe against intervention by whom? Does the governor (?) call in the State troopers (?) to take senators who have left the chamber back to their workplace, hand-cuffed? That is what I would call a forced democracy. I would like to learn more about these procedures when I am in Madison next week.
**




