Saturday, February 11, 2012

Nuclear Coincidence

Luckily enough it was only a coincidence and not a nuclear incident. Yesterday I read in the local newspaper BZ that the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) has approved the building of two new power reactors in the States whereas a few kilometers from Freiburg just across the Rhine River French and German antinuclear activists demanded the shut-down of the French nuclear power station at Fessenheim. Mind you not all is black and white.

While Germany has decided to phase out nuclear power, the NRC approved the construction of two new light water high-pressure nuclear reactors of the Westinghouse A1000 type at the existing Vogtei site in Georgia.

Lucky cows grazing in the shadow of the cooling towers
of the existing Vogtei nuclear power station (Photo dpa)
The last approval of a reactor in the States dates back to 1978 just one year before the nuclear accident occurred at the Three Mile Island site near Harrisburg, Pennsylvania.

Three Mile Island
According to Westinghouse the A1000 features proven technology, innovative passive safety systems, and economic competitiveness by improved and more efficient operations. In addition the innovative A1000 offers:

Is fewer also better? 
The NRC's vote was a 4 to 1 decision. Its chairman Gregory Jaczko raised considerable safety concerns: I cannot support this approval as if Fukushima did not happen, whereas the Obama administration is looking forward to the creation of 25,000 new jobs and focusses on the usual argument of reducing the US dependence on fossil energy.

In Germany following the melt-downs at the Fukushima reactor plant and defying strong opposition within her own Christian Democratic party, chancellor and physicist Angela Merkel forced the immediate shut down of 8 of Germany's oldest nuclear power stations with the last 9 to be phased out by 2022.

While Merkel and French President Sarkozy (also referred to as Merkozy) are walking and working hand in hand suffocating the Greeks* by trying to keep them in the Euro zone, they have completely different views on atomic energy.
*forcing the upgrade to central European standards of a traditionally self-contained Greek economy that is living on olives and retsina and has a record 25% of the active population occupied in administration

With the Siberian cold wave currently sweeping over Germany into France 60 million freezing French suddenly use twice the electrical energy of 80 million Germans. The reason is that many houses in France have electrical heating and rely heavily on our neighbor’s 58 power reactors producing nearly 80% of all electrical energy. Due to the heavy demand in France Germany presently is exporting electricity across the Rhine!

This is why Sarkozy when visiting one of the oldest nuclear sites in France operating at Fessenheim since 1975 stated: The electricity you produce is indispensable for the people.

The President in the Control Room. Doesn't he look as if he had lost control?


In the meantime German anti-atomic protesters tried to join their French colleagues on the other side of the Rhine River but in vain, the French riot police blocked the bridge with the argument they must protect their president. So the gendarmes and not the president read black on yellow: Merkozy sortons ensemble du nucléaire.

German protesters facing French riot police carrying banners
and the photo of a deformed child from Chernobyl (photo BZ)
When the French activists were eventually allowed to articulate their arguments against nuclear power they were told bluntly: There are rigorous safety rules. When these are observed the power station is safe. Sarkozy stepped up the tone: Anyone who wants to close Fessenheim is commiting a political swindle, he said to the applause of Fessensheim's work force when mentioning the hundreds of jobs depending on their nuclear power station. Sarkozy concluded: France's atomic policy is our force; we are not going to change it.

Referring to the demand of 400 politicians in Alsace who had asked for the immediate shut-down of the Fessenheim reactor complex Freiburg's mayor Dieter Salomon (Green) commented: The President is turning a blind eye on reality and ignoring the worries of the people. He asked Merkel to discuss the issue with Sarkozy in their next tête-à-tête.

No comments:

Post a Comment